Demystifying electrical generators and decibel levels

This article is written by George Long at Aggreko, after I had some concerns in how close we can place the size generators we needed to our stage without there being any issues of generator noise bleeding into the film. I had asked him to help ensure we were receiving “whisper quiet” generators. Here is his very well thought out reply:

First off, there’s no industry or any other standard that is “whisper quiet”, it’s a marketing term.

Film grade – surprisingly the “crystal sync” phrase didn’t get referred to. Film grade would simply mean that the generator has some sort of electronic governing versus mechanical speed control. Think your average gas generator that cycles according to load – you drop a higher demand on it and for a second or so, the voltage drops as the engine tries to catch up. This is caused by magnetic resistance imposed in the generator end – As the demand increases (trying to draw more out of the straw as it were), the increase causes more magnetic resistance which needs to be compensated for within the windings.

generators-large

Twin pack 1.5 MW Generators capable of providing electricity to 330 households

Think of it like this – you’re towing a boat down the highway and have cruise control on going 65 MPH. If that road is flat, the amount of energy required to keep it going at 65 MPH remains the same. However, if you hit a hill that load (the boat) starts to slow down the truck because the amount of available energy, assuming all factors are constant, exceeds the energy available to get up that hill – so what does the cruise control do? It applies more fuel to bring the vehicle back to 65. Typically there’s a lull where the engine basically has to catch up to the load. The same works in reverse, you crest that hill and start to go down and there’s less demand (load) on the truck and the cruise control doesn’t need to feed as much into the engine to keep the speed up.

With generators it’s roughly the same thing – as the load, in this case, amperage demand increase, it’s like hitting that hill. However we want the speed to remain constant always ~ speed = frequency/Hertz. If it was just mechanically governed (some construction generators have this with a bar you pull out to set engine speed), there’s a lag as the engine demands more fuel, and your lights dim, etc. With electronic governing, the generator senses things like the RPM and voltage a lot sooner than when the demand is there and compensates earlier/faster. Think of this like if you see the hill coming and you start to feed more into the engine prior to reaching the hill with your boat. You don’t notice the lag as much, if at all. Maybe another way of thinking about electronic generators control is using a super computer to calculate pi versus your I Phone app. You get there both ways but it’s a lot faster with the super computer.

Typically any filming or taping needs a steady sine wave at a precise Hertz or frequency. This is to ensure that the image speed remains consistent but it’s really a moot point. The plants have Deep Sea electronic controllers in them which regulate all the applicable elements to ensure this.

65db – Where? At 3 M? 7M? Engine end? Controller end? Averaged? Here’s a handy chart on average noise levels –

Environmental Noise

Weakest sound heard

0dB

Whisper Quiet Library at 6′

30dB

Normal conversation at 3′

60-65dB

Telephone dial tone

80dB

City Traffic (inside car)

85dB

Train whistle at 500′, Truck Traffic

90dB

Jackhammer at 50′

95dB

Subway train at 200′

95dB

Level at which sustained exposure may result in hearing loss

90 – 95dB

Hand Drill

98dB

Power mower at 3′

107dB

Snowmobile, Motorcycle

100dB

Power saw at 3′

110dB

Sandblasting, Loud Rock Concert

115dB

Pain begins

125dB

Pneumatic riveter at 4′

125dB

Even short term exposure can cause permanent damage – Loudest recommended exposure WITH hearing protection

140dB

Jet engine at 100′

140dB

12 Gauge Shotgun Blast

165dB

Death of hearing tissue

180dB

Loudest sound possible

194dB

 

OSHA Daily Permissible Noise Level Exposure

Hours per day

Sound level

8

90dB

6

92dB

4

95dB

3

97dB

2

100dB

1.5

102dB

1

105dB

.5

110dB

.25 or less

115dB

 

Perceptions of Increases in Decibel Level

Imperceptible Change

1dB

 Barely Perceptible Change

3dB

Clearly Noticeable Change

5dB

About Twice as Loud

10dB

About Four Times as Loud

20dB

 

Sound Levels of Music

Normal piano practice

60 -70dB

Fortissimo Singer, 3′

70dB

Chamber music, small auditorium

75 – 85dB

Piano Fortissimo

84 – 103dB

Violin

82 – 92dB

Cello

85 -111dB

Oboe

95-112dB

Flute 

92 -103dB

Piccolo

90 -106dB

Clarinet

85 – 114dB

French horn

90 – 106dB

Trombone

85 – 114dB

Tympani & bass drum

106dB

Walkman on 5/10

94dB

Symphonic music peak

120 – 137dB

Amplifier, rock, 4-6′

120dB

Rock music peak

150dB

NOTES:

  • One-third of the total power of a 75-piece orchestra comes from the bass drum.
  • High frequency sounds of 2-4,000 Hz are the most damaging. The uppermost octave of the piccolo is 2,048-4,096 Hz.
  • Aging causes gradual hearing loss, mostly in the high frequencies.
  • Speech reception is not seriously impaired until there is about 30 dB loss; by that time severe damage may have occurred.
  • Hypertension and various psychological difficulties can be related to noise exposure.
  • The incidence of hearing loss in classical musicians has been estimated at 4-43%, in rock musicians 13-30%.
  • Recent NIOSH studies of sound levels from weapons fires have shown that they may range from a low of 144 dB SPL for small caliber weapons such as a 0.22 caliber rifle to as high as a 172 dB SPL for a 0.357 caliber revolver. Double ear protection is recommended for shooters, combining soft, insertable ear plugs and external ear muffs.
    At 7 M, the “rating” of the 200 is 70 dbA – so less than a singer. Then add to this the inverse law of squares which says that any intensity is inversely proportional to the square of the distance from the source. A quick rule of thumb is sound level will decrease 6 db for every time the distance is doubled, although the calculations are slighting more complex than that.

IMG_1493

SIMPLE EQUATION FOR PREDICTING A SOUND LEVEL:

If you measure a sound level 70 = dB
at distance
d1 =7 m = 22.965 ft

then at distance
d2 = 20m = 65.616 ft

the inverse square law predicts a sound level
I2 = 50 dB

i2/i1=[d1/d2]

Thank you, Geo! He also collaborated on our Electricity Guide if you would like to read up even more about power.